ChatGTP and the quest for excess return

By Christian Schmitt, Senior Portfolio Manager at Ethenea

New tools such as ChatGPT will permanently change the work of all market participants and investors. At the same time, these tools harbour brand new risks for investors.

The article “ChatGPT Can Decode Fed Speak, Predict Stock Moves From Headlines” was one of the most-read articles on financial news portal Bloomberg in April. Artificial intelligence in general and, specifically, the chatbot ChatGPT are also hot topics. The relentless quest for excess return, so-called alpha – returns in excess of the expected return based on market risk (beta) – is an ongoing theme that has been on the minds of almost all financial market participants for decades. So it’s no surprise that ChatGPT and other similar language models are now being used for these purposes. One of the first scientific papers on this subject, to which the first part of the heading of the aforementioned Bloomberg article refers, asks the exciting question in its title, “Can ChatGPT Forecast Stock Price Movements?”. The short answer is yes. At least, it can one day ahead.

Admittedly, after a few years of experience in capital markets, it is not easy to keep a straight face when speaking of the plethora of possible sources of excess return. Alpha has always been a very delicate flower and also very short-lived. And that will always be the case. The discovery of supposed new sources of alpha – which has increased exponentially of late due for one to the improvement in the technological possibilities – will do nothing to change that. The search for ever new sources of alpha heats up a race that is almost impossible to win with these very means.

Herd mentality of investors

An example from the early years of my career illustrates the underlying issue very well and has been repeated countless times in a similar vein in the market since then and there is every likelihood that it will be repeated in the coming years with investment products labelled “artificial intelligence”.

The actual name and provider of this market-neutral product are not important here. The investment approach used and the underlying technique were state-of-the-art not quite 20 years ago and, with a size of almost EUR 10 billion at its peak, it wasn’t a niche product either. The investment strategy can be summed up, in highly simplified terms, as “buy the prospectively most attractive widely diversified equities in the market and sell the prospectively most unattractive equities in the market”. The market risk (beta) was effectively zero, so one could concentrate fully on continuously siphoning off alpha. The strategy worked phenomenally well at the start and delivered constantly positive performance without major fluctuations in price.

While on the surface of the market everything was relatively calm, the fund suddenly lost value day after day to the tune of the aggregate performance of multiple months. Investors were horrified and perplexed. What had happened? Using the new technological means and data many market participants had analysed the markets to find out which equities produced the easiest and most reliable excess returns in hindsight. Unsurprisingly, because the same data were examined with the same means, the same results were arrived at. Many investors simply had the same securities in their portfolios. As soon as investors had to sell to any appreciable extent, the shares came under pressure and a chain reaction was triggered. It was an important and instructive experience for many investors, which went down in the capital market history books under the chapter heading Quant Crash 2007.

For the sake of full disclosure, here’s what happened next in our example. Some of the losses were very quickly recouped in the first countermovement. The strategy was tweaked based on the lessons learned and made it through the crisis year of 2008 very well. Thereafter, however, it went into steady decline, without ever being able to get close to matching the successes of the backtesting or of the first few months and fulfilling the ambitions it proclaimed. After around eight and a half years, in 2015, the product that was once worth billions was taken off the market.

The example given above is instructive and helpful in many respects. It shows clearly that the herd mentality of investors presents a risk that cannot be underestimated not only at overall market level but also at individual security level. Interestingly, this risk does not correlate with traditional risk factors such as debt, valuation, cyclicality, beta and others. For that reason, it is infinitely more difficult to protect oneself from these positions referred to as crowded trades. While diversification of the portfolio essentially protects the portfolio, it is the investment strategy itself that harbours the potential risk here. Particular caution is thus advised in the case of both very popular investment strategies and new, innovative approaches that promise above-average returns and – therefore attract lots of investment – on the back of fresh backtesting, newly discovered alpha factors or new technological possibilities.

In addition to these immediate risks that arise at very short notice, in the medium to long term this example shows how quickly sources of alpha dry up. Practice and theory show that this tends to be the rule rather than the exception.

Reading the story behind the headline

What does this mean in concrete terms? Sure, headlines like “ChatGPT can predict share price movements” are intriguing. But, for the reasons outlined, they don’t send us into either a panic or raptures. That said, new tools such as ChatGPT will permanently change the work of all market participants and investors. Just like pocket calculators, computers and the internet before it. To assess opportunities and risks going forward it is therefore essential to understand the evolution and what the potential implications of this development will be.

This first financial paper on ChatGPT shows that at least one existing trend in the financial industry is being reinforced: the focus on ever shorter trading intervals, where day-to-day investments based on headlines no longer provoke any head-shaking to speak of. Perhaps the value of active management today consists in reading the story behind the headline. Let’s see if this is declared an official source of alpha!

Christian Schmitt
Christian Schmitt

Press contact

Wim Heirbaut

Senior PR Consultant, Befirm

Get updates in your mailbox

By clicking "Subscribe" I confirm I have read and agree to the Privacy Policy.

About Ethenea

ETHENEA offers a wide range of attractive investment opportunities for different investor profiles: risk-minimised, balanced and equity-focused.

Capital preservation and the achievement of stable long-term returns are key components of the investment philosophy of the Ethna Funds. The fund management consistently realises this objective through active management and flexible asset allocation across various sectors and asset classes.

ETHENEA wants to make a contribution and offer responsible and sustainable investment solutions. Therefore, ESG criteria are an important part of the investment processes of all Ethna Funds (Article 8 SFDR).

Further information and legal information can be found at


PRESS RELEASE – not an official document

We would like to point out that all data and information made available to you has been thoroughly researched by ETHENEA. However, with regard to its correctness and completeness, we cannot assume any liability or warranty for damages incurred either by the recipient of this information or by third parties, either directly or indirectly. In the event that this text is published in any form and to any extent, the publishing entity (editorial office of the newspaper or associated or commissioned third parties, website, podcast, etc.) is obliged to include the necessary disclaimers and legal notices. In addition, in this context, we refer to our legal information: The information contained in the attached document does not constitute a solicitation, offer or recommendation to buy or sell units in the fund or to engage in any other transaction.  It is intended solely to provide the reader with an understanding of the key features of the fund, such as the investment process, and is not deemed, either in whole or in part, to be an investment recommendation. The information provided is not a substitute for the reader's own deliberations or for any other legal, tax or financial information and advice. Neither the investment company nor its employees or Directors can be held liable for losses incurred directly or indirectly through the use of the contents of this document or in any other connection with this document. The currently valid sales documents in German (sales prospectus, key information documents (PRIIPs-KIDs) and, in addition, the semi-annual and annual reports), which provide detailed information about the purchase of units in the fund and the associated opportunities and risks, form the sole legal basis for the purchase of units. The aforementioned sales documents in German (as well as in unofficial translations in other languages) can be found at and are available free of charge from the investment company ETHENEA Independent Investors S.A. and the custodian bank, as well as from the respective national paying or information agents and from the representative in Switzerland. The paying or information agents for the funds Ethna-AKTIV, Ethna-DEFENSIV and Ethna-DYNAMISCH are the following: Austria, Belgium, Germany, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg: DZ PRIVATBANK S.A., 4, rue Thomas Edison, L-1445 Strassen, Luxembourg; France: CACEIS Bank France, 1-3 place Valhubert, F-75013 Paris; Italy: State Street Bank International – Succursale Italia, Via Ferrante Aporti, 10, IT-20125 Milano; Société Génerale Securities Services, Via Benigno Crespi, 19/A - MAC 2, IT-20123 Milano; Banca Sella Holding S.p.A., Piazza Gaudenzio Sella 1, IT-13900 Biella; Allfunds Bank S.A.U – Succursale di Milano, Via Bocchetto 6, IT-20123 Milano; Spain: ALLFUNDS BANK, S.A., C/ Estafeta, 6 (la Moraleja), Edificio 3 – Complejo Plaza de la Fuente, ES-28109 Alcobendas (Madrid); Switzerland: Representative: IPConcept (Schweiz) AG, Münsterhof 12, Postfach, CH-8022 Zürich; Paying Agent: DZ PRIVATBANK (Schweiz) AG, Münsterhof 12, CH-8022 Zürich. The paying or information agents for HESPER FUND, SICAV - Global Solutions are the following: Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg: DZ PRIVATBANK S.A., 4, rue Thomas Edison, L-1445 Strassen, Luxembourg; Italy: Allfunds Bank S.A.U – Succursale di Milano, Via Bocchetto 6, IT-20123 Milano; Switzerland: Representative: IPConcept (Schweiz) AG, Münsterhof 12, Postfach, CH-8022 Zürich; Paying Agent: DZ PRIVATBANK (Schweiz) AG, Münsterhof 12, CH-8022 Zürich. The investment company may terminate existing distribution agreements with third parties or withdraw distribution licences for strategic or statutory reasons, subject to compliance with any deadlines.